Tuesday, 1 November 2011

The great difficulty with politics is, that there are no established principles


There have been many exits in politics; many dignified, many reluctantly, some explosively, others indignantly, even petulantly. Few however, have been as undignified as the spectacle witnessed by members of the Labour party in Scotland at the weekend by Iain Gray, the man whom history will probably judge as being unique amongst Holyrood Labour leaders, for not having had one positive thing to say about his party, political philosophy or opponents during his three year tenure.

In his outpouring of bile at the weekend he devoted an exceptional paragraph shifting the blame of his and his parties failures to a few nameless individuals.

This afternoon we begin the process proper of electing a new Scottish leader for a new devolved Scottish Labour party.

I say to the candidates.  Don’t kid yourself.

You will be attacked.  You will be smeared.  You will be lied about.  You will be threatened. 

The cybernats and the bedsit bloggers will call you traitor, quisling, lapdog and worse.  They will question your appearance, your integrity and your sexuality.  They will drag your family and your faith into the lies and the vitriol.  If you are a woman it will be worse. 

It is no consolation to know that any journalist or commentator who gives you a fair hearing will suffer the same. 

This is the poison some have brought into our politics and it is vile. 

It is time we started talking openly about it and it is time the SNP did something about it. 

They know who some of these people are.

This is not how you build a better Scotland and Scotland deserves better.

But those who bring light suffer burning.  You will stand up to it and you should be proud to do so
.
    

As only one of a handful of bloggers to be pursued by the Scottish press and as far as I'm aware the only one to be hounded out of a job, I took fair exception to the utterly shambolic and pathetic attempt Iain Gray made to have one final kick at those he perceived to have brought about his downfall. Particularly his defence of 'any journalist or commentator who gives you a fair hearing.' Boo-fucking-hoohoo. 

For the record, I have never written or said anything "deeply unpleasant" about any Labour politician...or any other sort. I have never called a Unionist a traitor, quisling or lapdog...although I can't see why a fluffy lapdog would be considered offensive. I've never threatened Ian Gray, questioned his sexuality or dragged his family into lies and vitriol, although I confess to putting an SNP rosette on his wife's jacket as she and Mr Gray strolled along a beach on a winters day for the cameras... As to his integrity and appearance, these are the standards which politicians put upon themselves for election. I've found, as have the Scottish electorate, that Iain Gray is lacking in both.

The main reason the Labour Party has lost control of it's personal fiefdom, is not entirely down to the Tartan Overlords large shiny, smiley face. Rather, it is down to thousands of people in Scotland taking exception to the one sided, biased, blatant propaganda that has passed and still passes for impartial news in our newspapers and the state broadcaster. These people fed up with the lies and one sided nature of the Scottish media have discovered the internet, which has opened up the opportunity to search, research and respond.
 
As our newspapers shrink in actual paper sales, they have looked to an internet presence as the means to keep their shareholders happy and have created on-line forums to drive advertising revenue. Unfortunately, they have discovered that you can't have open access without the punters actually availing themselves of it. So, the past ten years have seen a Labour press release, with the obligatory kick at the SNP end up in the Scotsman straight from London Labour HQ, verbatim. Within moments of it appearing on-line, those of us with opinions on how Scotland will run better as an Independent country are ready to opine, and use actual facts to combat the press release. This is frowned upon in unionist Scotland. So what we mostly see are stories in the Scotsman coming on-line at obscure times of the night, always with sickening comments from Union supporters, invariably hours before Joe McPublic has had an opportunity to comment. These first posters do not engage in debate, instead they have brought, to paraphrase Iain Gray, 'vile poison into our politics'. Naturally, comments arise that these are people deep within Johnson press fighting to preserve the union at all costs. Much like Kevin McKenna confessed in his Independence 'epiphany' piece in last weeks Observer, that he and the Guardian man are both Unionists, so one must surmise are the majority of those scrivening behind the scenes at Johnson Towers. So for Gray to cry foul that those with the most power are victims, fair sticks in the craw. 

Gray will go down in Scottish political history as the man who lived up to his name, a cheap and obvious dig, but really what is our collective memory of him? Scuttling into a sandwich shop to escape natural Labour supporters concerned about the closure of a respite centre for the disabled, fag cupped in hand like a dodgy security guard gathering courage outside Holyrood on Thursday mornings before FMQ's or standing up in the chamber gesturing to Salmond to 'come ahead'.

He who fears being conquered is certain of defeat

Where Mr Gray's logic falls down, is in his belief that there is some secret cybernat army being marshalled by the upper echelons of the SNP, directing teams of Internet savvy operators to attack Labour at all costs. The cybernat is a Labour construct, there is no such thing. Instead there is a large, and growing number of people who are pissed off at the continual propaganda coming from the Unionist media which controls Scotland. That some professional members of the SNP buy into this construct is rather concerning. Perhaps it's easier for them to go down the knee jerk response road for fear of upsetting the horses and actually challenging those who control our daily news. 










12 comments:

Stevie said...

""""as far as I'm aware the only one to be hounded out of a job,"""

I'm truly sorry to hear that Mark, I didn't know.

As far as a controlled army of cybernats - I discovered there is no need to organise anything, there are so many pro-independence people (and not necessarily SNP) out there, everywhere you go, that it's quite breathtaking.

We have what we only ever had in 1976 to a degree, a movement for independence. A movement of passionate, relentless people who will not stop whatever the referendum result is, should it be just FFA.

Again Mark - we'll have our revenge served up cold.

Conan the Librarian™ said...

Well said Mark.

My modest little contribution to the cause is now on Wikipedia(!):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scotsman

For now anyway...

Weegiewarbler said...

Nice wee article Mark. I shall be sharing of course.
Am I a Cybernat? I suppose I must be, becuase I'm certainly no unionist. However, I don't live in a bedsit, so perhaps I'm not legitimate... enough.

Anonymous said...

YO Monty,

"as far as I'm aware the only one to be hounded out of a job"-Mar
What about Wardog? (He also has the distinction, I believe, of being the only pro-NAT vile blogger to have a post 'moderated' by you).

Bobelix said...

Cybernat Central Control wid hae us aw believe these thoosands o' oanline message manipulaturs are acting independently. This is, natcherully, complete c**p. Indoctrynashun seshuns tak place regellurly at centres with codenames like "Milne's Bar", "The Scotia" or "The Gellions" where groups wi' as menny uz 3 or even 4 have been sited knoacking back products wirra wurd "Scoatch" onn ra label and spreading subversive rumers aboot Ian Gray's inabulity tae kick a ba'. It is nae coincidence that, wi'in weeks o' these meetins, base calumnies about Unionist poalisys appear on Facebook and Twitter. An' they'd huv us believe it's no' a plot! Well, Ian Gray telt me himsel that it is, and he's goat an honest face* so Ah believe him - an ra Daily Record (some folk say they've fired almost a' their churnalists and are jist making it up, but that's obviously mair Cybernat proppyganda). How youse aw cin be deceived by aw this computer blethers, Ah've goat nae idea (funny enough, somewan sed that tae me in ra pub the ither night, "Boab, yeh've nae idea").
*He keeps it at hame in a jeely-jaur.

Administrator said...

Yo Cynicus! What are you 12 years old, do you wear one of those special side fitting truck drivers caps? ;)

Old fruit, I have no idea what you are talking about. The only person or persons I have ever had cause to 'moderate' were emissaries of Viagara or loathsome hacks from a 'newspaper' with hacked the phone messages of a brutally murdered young girl.

Wardog is a friend and a dashed fine architect.

pip pip

Observer said...

Does Ian Gray actually sit down & read the posts on the Hootsman & other forums? I detect a trend here, Brian Monteith was also writing about ''cybernats'' the other day. No doubt there will be journalists who would be quite happy to make a story up about the ''blackberry ring'', which is a figment of the imagination, but that has never stopped hacks before.

If Iain or any journalists are reading this, then may I direct you to the posts from self-described Labour activists which rival & exceed any lies or vitriol posted by the ''cybernats'' & which are to be found on most forums.

The internet is a robust place, which is not for the faint hearted. It is clearly unfair to single out one set of posters & imply that they alone are at fault, when there is widespread abuse to be found on practically any thread you read.

However, given that it appears to me that a trap is being laid here, then, given the example we already have of what befell Mark & Wardog - be careful out there cybernats. Don't give any hostages to fortune.

Vronsky said...

It's quite simple - either the independence view is overwhelmingly the majority, or unionists can't spell, can't write, don't speak English or have problems with new technology. I can't think of anything else that could explain the massive assymetry of posts on websites. It is of course this assymmetry which worries the unionists. Poor souls, they're in about the same emotional position as the defenders at Rourke's Drift when all those gazillions of Zulus suddenly rose over the horizon. Look at the white faces in the opening moments of ths video. Familiar?

And the response from the palefaces is - er - a Welsh song. 'Swing Low, Sweet Chariot' wouldn't quite have cut it, I suppose.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODM1RJe4FvQ&feature=related

Observer said...

Gray is doing an encore in the Hootsman today. It really is hysterical stuff.

http://www.scotsman.com/news/cartoon/iain_gray_cybernat_attacks_serve_to_damage_our_country_1_1946858

'' I am increasingly worried about it undermining the decency of the country I love, damaging the freedoms its citizens enjoy, and poisoning the vital debate we now face on the future of that country. I think all right thinking Scots, of whatever political persuasion, should be worried, too.''

As is pointed out in the attached thread, most Scots don't actually know what cybernats are.

The man has got it bad. Must have been all those Subway jokes.

Nikostratos said...

For the record, I have never written or said anything "deeply unpleasant" about any Labour politician...or any other sort. I have never called a Unionist a traitor, quisling or lapdog...

yeah ya did!

For the record, I have written and said anything "deeply unpleasant" things about Labour politicians...or any other sort. I have called a Unionist a traitor, quisling or lapdog...

see there is the evidence

Jason said...

I suppose making false cklaims about people bullying women is ok then Mark. So u must surely have won an unfair dismissal case if you were hard done to?

Administrator said...

I haven't said anything about Iain Davidson...oh you mean about a certain Labour councillor wanting his chamber suspension rescinded from the minutes after his misogynistic comments to the lady convenor...

You know, I'm still waiting on Labour's lawyers getting in touch.

Smell the cheese.

Smell the cheese.
Former vile blogger Montague Burton aka Mark MacLachlan

The equally bored.

Lend With Care

Lendwithcare.org microloans from CARE International - Banner Ad

Colour me chuffed.

Colour me chuffed.
Thanks to everyone who made up their own mind.

Children in tweed.

Children in tweed.
14th place. Thanks again to everyone with a pulse and a brain.

BIG BLOG ARCHIVE...click on links below for OLDER POSTS